Past modals in English: should have, could have, must have
By Michael McGettrickUpdated 12 October 2026
A past modal is modal + + . The modal shows what you mean about the past:
| Meaning | Example |
|---|---|
| : | . . |
. | |
| : | . |
| , | . |
| , | . |
Quick check
Now use it: three quick questions on the chart above. The full practice is further down.
Pick the right one
0/3Read the words in brackets. Then tap the word that fits.
Her coat is gone. She have left. (I'm sure.)
He have seen us. He was looking the other way. (I'm sure he didn't.)
I don't know why she's late. She have missed the bus. (Maybe.)
All of them look back at the past.
Modal + have + the third form
Take a guess about now, and add + . Now the guess is about the past:
Two rules, the same for every modal:
| Rule | Right | Wrong |
|---|---|---|
| have never changes | . | She must has left. |
. | I should have went. |
The not goes on the modal: .
.In speech, have is short: should've, must've, could've. Say it that way. But write it out, and never write should of: it sounds the same, but of is always wrong here.
Must have and can't have: sure about the past
You didn't see it happen. But you can see the signs now, and they leave only one answer:
. rained .. .
- .
- .
Two bowls of porridge. The full one: nobody ate it, so he can't have been hungry. The empty one: all of it is gone, so he must have been hungry.
Couldn't have is also a sure no:
. .Might have and could have: maybe
When you are , use might have, may have or could have. They all mean the same here:
| Word | Example |
|---|---|
. | |
. | |
. |
The not form of maybe is might not have (or may not have):
. (Maybe she didn't hear
it.)
- She must have left.I’m sure: yes
- She might have left.maybe
- She can’t have left.I’m sure: no
Could have: possible, but it didn't happen
Could have has a second job. It says something , but it :
, .. .. .
Two short sentences people say all the time:
.(after something bad, but not too bad)!(to someone who took a big risk)
Often an if part is hiding: (if you had wanted to) you could have come. That is the third conditional, in conditional sentences.
Should have: the right thing you didn't do
Should have says it was the thing to do, and you do it. About yourself, it is a regret. About someone else, it is blame:
booked . .!
Shouldn't have is the other way round: you did it, and it was wrong.
.How much blame? From a small idea to a real complaint:
- You could have called.it was possible
- You might have called!a little annoyed (mostly British)
- You should have called.you were wrong not to
Ought to have means the same as should have and is a little more
formal: .
Needn't have or didn't need to?
Both say something was . The question is: did you do it?
| Form | Did you do it? | Example |
|---|---|---|
| ( ) | . . | |
, . |
So if you did it and it was for nothing, say needn't have:
. !Needn't is mostly British. American English usually says didn't need to or didn't have to for both.
Common mistakes
| Wrong | Right | Why |
|---|---|---|
| I should of called. | I should have called. | Always have, never of. |
| She must has left. | She must have left. | Have never changes. |
| We should have went. | We should have gone. | . |
What to do next
- Look at your room. Finish this: Somebody must have...
- Think of yesterday. Finish this: I should have...
- Do the drills below.