Concession: However It Turns Out
English does concession with a suffix. Take a wh- word, bolt -ever on the end, and you are done: whatever, wherever, whoever, however, whichever. The grammar looks after itself and nobody has to think.
French has no -ever, and what it has instead is a set of structures that all mean roughly "it makes no difference which", all take the subjunctive, and all look enough like each other to be confused. This page sorts them out, and it ends with the spelling that A-level examiners like best: against .
The mood, at least, is never in doubt. A concession clause names a range of possibilities in order to say that the outcome is the same across all of them. Nothing in it is asserted. That is the subjunctive's job description, and the conjunctions page already establishes it for ; everything here is the same instinct applied to a different set of words.
The whatever system at a glance
| French | English | Standing in for |
|---|---|---|
| + subjunctive | whatever | an object or a thing |
| + subjunctive | wherever | a place |
| + subjunctive | whoever | a person |
| ()(s) + être | whatever, whichever | a noun after |
| / / pour + adj + | however (+ adjective) | a degree |
| ... () ... | whether ... or ... | two alternatives |
quoi que: whatever
replaces a thing in the clause, usually the object of the verb.
- , soutiendrai. (Whatever you do, I will back you.)
- ' arrive, . (Whatever happens, I will stay.)
- , décision . (Whatever you think about it, the decision is made.)
' arrive and ' (be that as it may) are worth learning as fixed units; both are extremely common in written French and both are useful in an essay.
où que: wherever
- , . (Wherever you go, I will find you.)
- ' , . (Wherever they are, they are safe.)
D' does the "from wherever" version: d' ' , .
There is no matching whenever. Do not build one. French uses , à n' moment, or with the indicative when the sense is repetition.
qui que: whoever
- , . (Whoever you are, you have to wait.)
- , s'. (Whoever did that must apologise.)
on its own means "anyone at all": n' à (I have not mentioned it to a soul). Its object twin is , "anything at all".
quel que: the one that agrees
This is the structure most likely to cost you a mark, because here is an adjective and it agrees with a noun that has not appeared yet. The shape is always plus plus the noun.
- , l'. (Whatever the price, I will buy it.)
- Quelle , n' excuse. (Whatever the reason, it is not an excuse.)
- , . (Whatever the results, we will carry on.)
- Quelles , . (Whatever the difficulties, she will succeed.)
Both halves move: agrees with the noun, and so does the verb, giving for a singular and for a plural. Write the noun first, then go back and fix the two words in front of it.
And note the spelling. is two words when it is followed by a verb; is one word when it means "some", as in . Quelque soit le prix is wrong.
si, aussi, pour + adjective: however
For "however" plus an adjective, French offers three near-identical patterns, all with and all subjunctive.
- , . (However difficult it is, we have to do it.)
- ' , n' . (However rich he is, he is not happy.)
- Pour intelligent ' , . (However clever he is, he is often wrong.)
is the everyday one, is neutral, pour is the most formal. Note that this has nothing to do with the conditional , and the golden rule does not apply to it.
One relative of these behaves differently and is worth knowing so it does not look like an error: plus adjective plus prefers the indicative. ' , n' . The reason is that concedes the quality as a fact rather than entertaining it.
If the "however" attaches to a quantity rather than to an adjective, use plus the noun: efforts ' , n'y (however hard he tries).
que ... ou ...: whether or not
The bare version handles alternatives, and it needs no other word at all.
- ' , à . (Whether he comes or not, we will leave at eight.)
- ' pleuve ' , match . (Rain or shine, the match will go ahead.)
- d' , c' décidé. (Whether you agree or not, it is decided.)
Notice that the second is repeated when a whole second clause follows, but and need nothing after them.
quoique versus quoi que
Now the trap. Two spellings, both subjunctive, and no help from the mood.
- (one word) = although, a synonym of .
- (two words) = whatever, standing in for a thing in the clause.
- Quoiqu' , n' . (Although he is rich, he is not happy.)
- ' , . (Whatever he does, he fails.)
The test that always works: try replacing it with . If the sentence still means what you intended, it is one word. If it collapses because the clause is missing an object, it is two.
A second clue is the clause itself. After , the verb has a gap where its object should be: ' has nothing after because is it. After , the clause is complete: quoiqu' is missing nothing.
Worked examples
- , d'. (Whatever you say, I will not change my mind.)
- , . (Wherever we go, it rains.)
- Quelles conséquences, . (Whatever the consequences, I will tell the truth.) - feminine plural noun, so both words move.
- , d' . (However tired you are, finish this job first.)
- ' d' , décision . (Whether she agrees or not, the decision is made.)
- , . (Although we are tired, we will carry on.) - concession, one word.
- ' , . (Be that as it may, we have to act.) - a fixed phrase worth having.
Common mistakes English speakers make
The first error is the agreement. Quel que soit les résultats and quelque soit la raison are both wrong in two different ways: must agree with the noun and must be two words.
The second is confusing and . Learn the bien que test, and apply it every time rather than trusting the shape of the sentence.
The third is inventing for "whenever". There is no such structure; use or .
The fourth is putting an indicative in a concession clause. Quoi que tu fais and où que tu vas are among the most visible errors an A-level script can contain, because the whole construction exists to mark non-assertion.
The fifth is over-reading the in as a conditional. It is not: it means "however", and the subjunctive after it is required rather than forbidden.
Finally, do not build ' on the pattern of the others. This one takes the indicative, ' , which is odd, is correct, and is worth remembering precisely because it looks wrong.
See also
- The subjunctive after conjunctions - bien que, the concession conjunction quoique is a synonym of, and the rest of the fixed list.
- The present subjunctive formation - the forms of faire, aller and être these clauses live on.
- Subjunctive or indicative - the assertion test that explains why concession is subjunctive territory.
- Interrogative quel and lequel - the agreeing quel that turns up again in quel que soit.
- si clauses - the other si, and why its golden rule does not touch si difficile que ce soit.
- The French grammar cheatsheet - the whole grammar map at a glance.