Ch 29 · Lesson 19

Mi lavis la manojn: la for the owner, and aches

Where the owner is obvious, replaces my and his; makes the owner explicit; and three ways to say it hurts: , , .

The short version

, not : the body rule

.

He broke his arm.
Why?

Where the owner is obvious, Esperanto usually says instead of a possessive: , I washed my hands. PMEG says this happens especially with body parts, clothing and relatives. To make the owner explicit, put it after , with for he, she and they: . is not wrong, just heavier.

: three ways to say it hurts

.

My back hurts.
Why?

With , the body part is the subject. is the usual modern form; , with the sufferer after , is also standard; and uses the compound noun. The older , with the person as an object, belongs to early texts.

The rule: la, not mia

la (the owner is obvious)the possessive (whose is the news)al si (the owner made explicit)What do the colours mean?

English marks the owner of every body part: my hands, his head. Esperanto usually does not. PMEG, the standard reference grammar:

, , . , , oj .

Often one uses instead of a possessive pronoun if the context clearly shows who the owner is. That happens especially often with body parts, clothing and relatives.

PMEG's examples cover all three:

  • . - He raised his head.
  • . - He often touches the brim of his hat with his hand.
  • , . - Tell Father I am diligent.

there is the speaker's father. PMEG glosses as = : the same meaning.

It is a preference, not a law. . is correct, only heavier than it needs to be.

Al si: making the owner explicit

When the bare could leave a doubt, put the owner after . With he, she and they that is the reflexive :

  • . - She washed her feet. (PMEG's example)
  • . - He broke his arm.

or there would mean another woman's feet, another s arm. The reflexive explains why.

When the possessive comes back

the possessive (whose is the news)What do the colours mean?

When whose it is matters, the possessive does real work:

  • , . - The doctor examined my hands, not yours.
  • . - She held my hand. Two people, two sets of hands.

The test: if you could drop the English my and lose nothing, use . If dropping it raises the question "whose?", keep the possessive.

Saying that something hurts

the possessiveal mi (the person it hurts)What do the colours mean?

Three forms are standard. With the verb (to hurt), the body part is the subject:

FormExampleNote
possessive .the usual form today
+ person .also standard
compound noun .I have a headache

The (), the main online dictionary, remarks that modern usage seems to prefer to the older , which you will meet in early texts.

The body part is the subject, so it takes no -n, and is the same for one bone or many (Esperanto verbs never change for person or number):

  • . - My bones ached after the long journey.

The compound noun works for any body part: (headache), (toothache), (stomach ache). This is ordinary compounding.

Mistakes English speakers make

WrongRightWhy
or a possessive, not both
(her own feet) her own feet:
. .the body part is the subject
the object of takes -n
is the tongue, the organ

Going further: The head and the face and the rest of the guide, when you want them. This lesson does not need them.

Read the full guide (optional) · 6 min read

Practice

Practise this lesson

7-question session

One question at a time, mixed across the exercises in this lesson. Miss one and it comes back round before the end.

Esperanto · Free printables

Worksheets for this lesson

Worksheets with answer keys built in. Open any one to view, print or save.

Free for members

The printable worksheets, infographics and PDFs are free with an account. Start a free week and download as many as you like.

Start your free week

Lesson 19 of 29 in this chapter

Back to the curriculum

What do the colours mean?