Ch 22 · Lesson 18

Si meaning whether, and si or quand

When means whether, the future is fine ( ). And takes the future for a future event: .

The short version

The that means whether breaks the rule

.

I do not know whether she will come.
Why?

When introduces an indirect question and means whether, it is a different word and the golden rule does not apply. takes a future quite happily. The test: swap if for whether in the English, and if the meaning survives, the future is fine.

Si meaning whether

the verb after sithe verb in the resulta future or conditional allowed after itWhat do the colours mean?

When asks an indirect question, it means whether, and the golden rule does not apply. The future and the conditional are both fine after it:

  • . - I don't know whether she will come.
  • . - He asked me whether I would come.
  • . - I wonder whether we will have time.

The test: swap if for whether in the English. If the meaning survives, it is the whether-, and the tense is free.

Si or quand?

the verb after sithe verb in the resulta future or conditional allowed after itWhat do the colours mean?

English puts a present after both if and when. French does it only after . After , a future event takes the future:

WordMeaningExample
maybe you will come , .
you are coming , .

The glosses: If you come, we will go to the cinema. When you come, we will go to the cinema.

Mistakes English speakers make

WrongRightWhy
no future after
no conditional after
shortens before ,
only before and
future event after

The last row is about a future visit, where careful French wants the future; is right for a habit (whenever you come), and in casual speech you will also hear it for a plan.

Going further: Type 1: real and likely and the rest of the guide, when you want them. This lesson does not need them.

Read the full guide (optional) · 4 min read

Practice

Practise this lesson

9-question session

One question at a time, mixed across the exercises in this lesson. Miss one and it comes back round before the end.

French · Free printables

Worksheets for this lesson

Worksheets with answer keys built in. Open any one to view, print or save.

Free for members

The printable worksheets, infographics and PDFs are free with an account. Start a free week and download as many as you like.

Start your free week

Lesson 18 of 28 in this chapter

Back to the curriculum

What do the colours mean?