Ch 31 · Lesson 16

Found or sought: qui connaît, qui connaisse

In a relative clause the mood says whether the thing exists: , but . Find it and the indicative returns.

The short version

Still looking for it? The subjunctive says so

.

I am looking for a flat that is quiet.
Why?

An indicative relative clause states a fact about something that exists: . When you are only looking for it, the subjunctive says it may not exist: . Find it and the indicative returns.

In a relative clause the subjunctive is not triggered by a word: it is a choice, and it says whether the thing exists. . - I know someone who knows German (they exist). . - I am looking for someone who knows German (if there is anyone).

indicative: it existssubjunctive: sought or deniedWhat do the colours mean?
AntecedentFrenchMood
found, known .indicative
sought .your choice
denied .subjunctive
between commas , , .indicative

The glosses: I have found a hotel that is quiet. I am looking for a hotel that is quiet. There is no hotel that is quiet. My hotel, which is quiet, is full.

The clause starts with an ordinary relative pronoun, or ; only the verb's mood moves. For the forms of , and , see the present subjunctive conjugation.

Found or sought

indicative: it existssubjunctive: sought or deniedWhat do the colours mean?

An indicative relative clause states a fact about something that exists. A subjunctive one states a requirement for something you are still looking for. The main verb is the giveaway: , , , .

  • . - I am looking for a flat that is quiet.
  • . - I would like a house that has a garden.
  • . - We need an employee who can drive.

Find the thing and the mood flips back, because now there is something to state a fact about:

  • . - I have found a flat that is quiet.
  • . - I have an employee who can drive.

On a scale from it exists to it does not, the mood follows the certainty:

It existsIt does not
  1. J’ai trouvé un guide qui connaît la région.found: a fact
  2. Je cherche un guide qui connaît la région.such guides exist
  3. Je cherche un guide qui connaisse la région.anyone, if there is one
  4. Il n’y a aucun guide qui connaisse la région.there is none

One sentence, two meanings

indicative: it existssubjunctive: sought or deniedWhat do the colours mean?

After , both moods are correct French. English says them the same way; French does not.

MoodFrenchWhat you claim
indicative .such a guide exists, maybe one in mind
subjunctive .anyone will do, if there is one

In everyday speech the indicative is common in both senses; the subjunctive is what spells the doubt out. Getting it wrong rarely sounds broken: it makes a claim you did not mean.

A definite article settles it. . - The guide who knows the area has arrived. has already picked the guide out, so the clause is a fact about him: indicative. (After , or a superlative the subjunctive comes back; see below.)

Going further: Personne, rien, aucun: nothing to point at and the rest of the guide, when you want them. This lesson does not need them.

Read the full guide (optional) · 4 min read

Practice

Practise this lesson

8-question session

One question at a time, mixed across the exercises in this lesson. Miss one and it comes back round before the end.

French · Free printables

Worksheets for this lesson

Worksheets with answer keys built in. Open any one to view, print or save.

Free for members

The printable worksheets, infographics and PDFs are free with an account. Start a free week and download as many as you like.

Start your free week

Lesson 16 of 26 in this chapter

Back to the curriculum

What do the colours mean?