Ch 33 路 Lesson 18Spanish 路 Chapter 33 路 Lesson 18 路 Grammar primer
Fumar es malo: where -ing is not the gerund
Three English -ing jobs the Spanish gerund cannot do: a subject ( ), after a preposition ( ) and describing a noun ( ). Plus the mistakes.
The short version
After a preposition, always the infinitive
, .
Why?Hide
English puts -ing after before, after, without and for. Spanish uses the infinitive after a preposition: , , . If a preposition sits in front, the next verb is an infinitive.
Trap 1: a subject or an activity is the infinitive
When English -ing names an activity, it is acting as a noun. Spanish uses the infinitive for that, never the gerund:
| Job | Spanish | English |
|---|---|---|
| subject | . | Smoking is bad. |
| saying | . | Seeing is believing. |
| what you like | . | I like cooking. |
| subject | . | Swimming is good exercise. |
| a sign | . | No smoking. |
The test: if you could put "the" in front of the English word (the smoking, the cooking), it is a noun, so Spanish wants the infinitive. More on that form on the uses of the infinitive.
Trap 2: after a preposition, the infinitive
After any preposition, single words and longer ones like alike, the verb is an infinitive:
| Preposition | Spanish | English |
|---|---|---|
| before leaving | |
| after eating | |
| sin | . | He/She left without saying anything. |
. | Thanks for coming. | |
. | I'm tired of waiting. | |
, . | On arriving, I rang my mother. |
English puts -ing after a preposition in all of these, which is why this is such a common gerund mistake. The old + gerund ( , as soon as he/she arrives) survives only in old-fashioned writing and some regional speech: do not copy it.
Trap 3: -ing describing a noun is que + verb
English lets -ing describe a noun directly: a box containing books. A Spanish gerund cannot, so rewrite with and a conjugated verb:
| Noun | Spanish | English |
|---|---|---|
| box | | a box containing books |
| man | | a man carrying a suitcase |
| letter | | a letter explaining everything |
Mistakes English speakers make
| Wrong | Right | Why |
|---|---|---|
| . | . | a subject: infinitive |
| after a preposition | |
| sin | | after a preposition |
| Me . | . | what you like is a noun |
| pan | | a gerund cannot describe a noun |
| leiendo, pediendo | , | -; e becomes i |
One trap catches good writers too: the gerund means "at the same time" or just before (at most an immediate result: , , he/she fell and broke a leg), not a later event. "He fled and was arrested later" needs :
.- He/She fled and was arrested later. Not ",".
Going further: The gerund at a glance and the rest of the guide, when you want them. This lesson does not need them.
Practice
Practise this lesson
10-question session
One question at a time, mixed across the exercises in this lesson. Miss one and it comes back round before the end.
Spanish 路 Free printables
Worksheets for this lesson
Worksheets with answer keys built in. Open any one to view, print or save.
Free for members
The printable worksheets, infographics and PDFs are free with an account. Start a free week and download as many as you like.
Start your free weekLesson 18 of 27 in this chapter