Ch 23 · Lesson 17Spanish · Chapter 23 · Lesson 17 · Grammar primer
Reported questions: me preguntó si
..., ...: yes/no questions take , open questions keep their question word and its accent, and the verb stays straight after it.
The short version
A yes/no question is reported with
.
Why?Hide
A yes or no question takes , not : . An open question keeps its question word and its written accent even though the question mark has gone, as in , and the verb stays straight after it, just as in the question.
Report a yes/no question with , an open question with its question word, and a command with plus the imperfect subjunctive:
.- He/She asked me if I was hungry..- He/She asked me where I lived..- He/She told me to come.
Reported questions and commands on one screen
| Direct | Reported | English |
|---|---|---|
¿ ? | . | ... asked if I was hungry. |
¿ ? | . | ... asked where the train was. |
¡! | . | ... told me to come. |
. | . | ... told me not to go out. |
After a past reporting verb the tenses step back, as in reported speech: becomes , becomes . The question marks go, because the sentence now states what was asked.
Reported yes/no questions: si
A question you can answer with yes or no is reported with :
| Direct | Reported | English |
|---|---|---|
¿ ? | . | ... asked if I wanted coffee. |
¿ ? | . | ... asked if I had finished. |
¿ ? | . | ... asked if I'd come tomorrow. |
The tense steps back only after a past reporting verb. After a present one, it stays:
.- He/She is asking me if I want coffee.
This si means whether
This is not the of if-sentences. It means whether, so it can take the future or the conditional, which the if- does not take in standard Spanish:
.- I don't know whether he/she will come., .- If you come, I'll help you.
Reported open questions: keep the question word
An open question keeps its question word, and the word keeps its written accent:
Me preguntó... - he/she asked me who he was, where it was, when it started, how much it cost.
| Direct | Reported | English |
|---|---|---|
¿ ? | . | ... asked what I wanted. |
¿ ? | . | ... asked when it started. |
¿ ? | . | ... asked why I was crying. |
¿ ? | . | ... asked how much it cost. |
The accent marks a question, with or without question marks. Where there is no question, there is no accent:
.- He/She asked me where I worked..- I live where I work.
In speech you will often hear before the question word: . That is correct Spanish and commonest in speech; careful writing usually leaves the out.
The verb comes straight after the question word
English moves the subject forward: "where the train was". Spanish normally keeps the order of the direct question, with the verb straight after the question word:
.- He/She asked me where the train was..- He/She asked me when the film started.
is the loose one: the subject may come before the verb, as in Ana . (He/She asked me why Ana didn't come.)
Going further: Reported commands: que + imperfect subjunctive and the rest of the guide, when you want them. This lesson does not need them.
Practice
Practise this lesson
10-question session
One question at a time, mixed across the exercises in this lesson. Miss one and it comes back round before the end.
Spanish · Free printables
Worksheets for this lesson
Worksheets with answer keys built in. Open any one to view, print or save.
Free for members
The printable worksheets, infographics and PDFs are free with an account. Start a free week and download as many as you like.
Start your free weekLesson 17 of 27 in this chapter